The landmark Supreme Court case Obergefell v. Hodges, which led to the legalization of same-sex marriage in the U.S. a decade ago, is marked by an unexpected friendship between its lead plaintiff, Jim Obergefell, and the defendant, Rick Hodges, the Ohio state health director at the time. A year post the historic June 26, 2015, ruling, Obergefell met Hodges at an LGBTQ advocacy event. Initially hesitant, Obergefell agreed to meet, and they quickly found common ground over coffee.
Hodges expressed admiration for Obergefell, referring to him as an “icon” and remarked on his bittersweet victory, acknowledging that Obergefell’s fight began after the loss of his partner, John Arthur, to ALS. The legal battle began when Obergefell learned their marriage wouldn’t be recognized on Arthur’s death certificate, prompting the initial lawsuit against the state.
Hodges, although required to defend Ohio’s ban on same-sex marriage professionally, held supportive personal views and sought ways to prepare for the potential outcome of the Supreme Court ruling. He had even organized a team of lawyers to craft a licensing system for same-sex marriages, anticipating a favorable ruling.
The friendship between Obergefell and Hodges stands out as a positive example amidst contentious social issues, highlighting the human capacity for understanding and collaboration. They regularly participate in events together and have developed a bond, meeting two to three times a year—especially during the 10th anniversary of the decision. Obergefell noted the rarity of such friendships between plaintiffs and defendants, expressing his gratitude for their relationship. Their story serves as a hopeful model in navigating complex societal challenges.
Photo credit
www.nbcnews.com
